Home Page > Learn Catholic > Divorce Wrong? > Guilty need affirmation
 Defending Families Against Forced No-Fault Divorce
NACSDC says divorced Catholics are among the most ardent supporters of marriage

In the Winter 1996 edition Jacob's Well Professional Newsletter, published by North American Conference of Separated and Divorced Catholics (NACSDC), the authors, Rick McCord, National Conference of Catholic Bishops Secretariat, and Kathy Brewer, President of NACSDC, state:

     "Divorce is one of the many bad things that can happen to good people."
     "Most people don't want a divorce.  Unfortunately, they just don't have the skills to stay married."
      "Divorce can be an extremely alienating experience.  Generally, people going through a divorce suffer a loss of self esteem and a deep sense of guilt, failure, and rejection.  They often turn to their faith community seeking affirmation and acceptance, especially if they haven't found it in their family."
     "On average, U.S. Catholics are only a little less likely to divorce than the general population. Obviously, then, parishes can neither ignore divorce nor exclude divorced people from their circle of care."
     This article's generalizations contradict authoritative Church teaching.

How the Church Views Divorce, NACSDC DISSENTING Mary'sAdvocates Analysis (see summary)
By Rick McCord, National Conference of Catholic Bishops Secretariat.  Editor's Note:  On November 18, 1996 "How the Church Views Divorce" was available to Diocesan Newspapers on the Associated Press.  Kathy Brewer, President of NACSDC helped Rick write this outstanding article. Article appeared in Winter 1996, Jacob's Well Professional Newsletter, publication of North American Conference of Separated and Divorced Catholics (NACSDC)
Divorce is one of the many bad things that can happen to good people.  When it does, I suggest that a church responds in a variety of ways, keeping two characteristics in mind.

First, the ministry should be multi-faceted.  It will need to deal with preventing divorces as well as helping those who are experiencing a divorce. Second, the ministry must focus on the needs of the people involved in the situation, especially the ones most in need of healing.

An extensive ministry to separated and divorced persons has been taking place in the Catholic Church for several decades.   Even so, questions are still asked about it. Does such a ministry detract from the church's duty to uphold the permanency of marriage?  What does this ministry seek to accomplish? What are its components?

Before discussing these questions, let me be clear about one thing. Divorce is a multi-leveled tragedy.  Nearly every family has been affected directly or indirectly by it.  Stories abound about the pain of broken relationships, the long journey to healing and recovery, the hurt sustained by children and other family members, the social costs calculated in school failures, increased poverty and delinquency. Sadly, divorce has become a major thread in our social fabric.  Everyone must reckon with it.  But how?

First, we must help people to see that divorce is not the only option in a troubled marriage.  Second, when a marriage does fail, people would be helped to move through a recovery process and ultimately to reintegration with their family and community.

Even before a couple ends up in crisis, the church ought to be offering them ways to strengthen their marriage.  Divorce prevention, though not the sole focus of the effort, is surely an important dimension of marriage education nowadays.  Couples want their marriages to succeed.  They know the risk involved.  A divorced Catholic woman told me, "Most people don't want a divorce.  Unfortunately, they just don't have the skills to stay married." 

 ------>  By stating that divorce happens to good people and nearly every family has been affected by divorce, divorce is defined as the subject and families are defined as the object.  Divorce is presented as something 'out there' with its own power and it just occurs.   In reality, people choose divorce, and according to Frank Furstenberg, Professor of Sociology at the University of Pennsylvania, and Andrew Cherlin, Professor of Public Policy in the Department of Sociology at John Hopkins University, research shows that four out of five marriages are ended unilaterally.  In other words, in eighty percent of divorces, there was one partner who did not want to divorce — there was one partner who wanted to save his/her children from the devastation of a broken home. (more, see Introduction)

Church teaching makes the distinction between the perpetrator and the victim. Catechism of the Catholic Church 2384-2386 states, "Divorce is a grave offense against the natural law. It claims to break the contract, to which the spouses freely consented, to live with each other till death. Divorce does injury to the covenant of salvation, of which sacramental marriage is the sign. Divorce is immoral also because it introduces disorder into the family and into society. ...  There is a considerable difference between a spouse who has sincerely tried to be faithful to the sacrament of marriage and is unjustly abandoned, and one who through his own grave fault destroys a canonically valid marriage"

If forcing a divorce on one's spouse and children in a sin, to excuse this sin by stating most people don't have the skills to stay married is a senseless as saying a father who sexually abused his daughter doesn't have the skill to practice chastity. Both the abused daughter in this example, and the abandoned spouse who is the victim of a forced no-fault divorce are called to forgive, but to deny that the perpetrator did anything wrong or immoral is a gross offense against justice.  There are no special skills required to avoid filing for a civil no-fault dioroce. 
 

 So, a systematic program of marriage enrichment and formation -- widely available and sponsored collaboratively by parishes, dioceses, spiritual centers, lay apostolic organizations -- is the first way for the church to respond to the tragedy of divorce. This is the preventative approach.  Another preventive strategy is a commitment to heal seriously troubled marriages. In this instance, a couple is poised over the edge.  Often they are separated and living as if they were already divorced.  Here the desired goal is that they reconcile and get their relationship back on track.  Increasingly, Catholic diocese and parishes are undertaking this important work, often with national ministry groups such as Retrouvaille and The Third Option.

Still, however, not all marriages can be saved and all divorces prevented. "Various reasons can unfortunately lead to the often irreparable breakdown of valid marriages," Pope John Paul II wrote in his 1981 message on the family.  On average, U.S. Catholics are only a little less likely to divorce than the general population. Obviously, then, parishes can neither ignore divorce nor exclude divorced people from their circle of care.

A first step for parish members and leaders is to acknowledge the existence of divorced Catholics in their midst and make them feel included in the life of the community.  Divorce can be an extremely alienating experience.  Generally, people going through a divorce suffer a loss of self esteem and a deep sense of guilt, failure, and rejection.  They often turn to their faith community seeking affirmation and acceptance, especially if they haven't found it in their family.

A feeling of welcome and inclusion comes from many ordinary gestures. A greeting, a conversation, and invitation to join this or that group, a specific mention in homilies and prayers -- all these are a broad form of ministry to divorced persons.

 ------>  Taking Pope John Paul II out of context gives the impression that he accepts and expects divorce.  In fact, in every no-fault divorce, one person files for divorce first (plaintif) and one person is the defendant. In every separation, one person leaves and one person remains.  The plaintiff or abandoning spouse certainly has it within his or her power to repair the breakdown.   The defendant, "the innocent party," is the person who's forced into an irrepariable breakdown.  In Familiaris Consertio, (sec. 83) the Pope writes, "Various reasons can unfortunately lead to the often irreparable breakdown of valid marriages. These include mutual lack of understanding and the inability to enter into interpersonal relationships. Obviously, separation must be considered as a last resort, after all other reasonable attempts at reconciliation have proved vain. 

Loneliness and other difficulties are often the lot of separated spouses, especially when they are the innocent parties. The ecclesial community must support such people more than ever. It must give them much respect, solidarity, understanding and practical help, so that they can preserve their fidelity even in their difficult situation; and it must help them to cultivate the need to forgive which is inherent in Christian love, and to be ready perhaps to return to their former married life.

The situation is similar for people who have undergone divorce, but, being well aware that the valid marriage bond is indissoluble, refrain from becoming involved in a new union and devote themselves solely to carrying out their family duties and the responsibilities of Christian life. In such cases their example of fidelity and Christian consistency takes on particular value as a witness before the world and the Church. Here it is even more necessary for the Church to offer continual love and assistance, without there being any obstacle to admission to the sacraments. "

 

At a more particular level, divorce persons need a structure to help them go through the grieving process.  The same is true of children in divorced families.  Here is where support groups are very valuable.  With the assistance of diocesan family ministry office or the North American Conference of Separated and Divorced Catholics, parishes can find the resources and training necessary to organize such groups.  Persons experiencing a divorce will likely feel burned out as they assume added responsibilities for childcare, household management, and maybe a second job.  All the more reason, then, for a group that can offer practical advise, and occasional baby sitter, and most of all, the prayerful assurance that life can and must go on.  Because they can offer so much, groups for the separated and divorced should be an ongoing gesture of the parish's ministry.

A program, such as Rainbows for All God's Children, that is designed to be offered in Catholic and public schools can be a lifeline for children bewildered and hurt by their parents' divorce.  Here, again, parishes can provide leadership on behalf of children. In doing so, the seeds may be sown for preventing future divorces.

 ------>  By acknowledging that divorcing people feel guilty, and then jumping to the need to grieve, Rick McCord ignores the natural role guilt plays for human beings.   If spouses are forcing divorce on their spouse and on their children (who are losing their God-given right to an intact family), they should feel guilty.  The guild should motivate them to correct their behavior.
Divorced Catholics have question about the status of their marriage in the church and their freedom to remarry.  For this reason, a staple of any ministry with divorced persons should be information on canonical annulments and assistance with the process of seeking one.

Will ministering to divorced persons compete with and distract from the church's duty to promote and strengthen marriages?  There is no reason why this should occur. Seeing both efforts as part of a larger ministry to families is essential. Divorced Catholics are often among the most ardent supports of marriage.  Many wish there were some way to bring their experience to bear on helping other couples prepare for marriage.

 ------>  If NACSDC is supplying Catholics with information regarding annulment which contradicts authoritative church teaching, no one is being helped. (more)
Conversely, those who are married -- if they're honest with themselves -- will recognize how delicately balanced relationships are and how fragile the marital bond can be.  This doesn't make it any less sacred or permanent.  It acknowledges that failure is a dimension of all human relationships, especially marriage, but that it's not the final word.  With God's grace, Christians journey through death to resurrection.  For some the journey takes place within the lifetime of one marriage.  For other it takes a different course.  It's the same journey though.  ------>  Rick McCord is correct when he states, "With God's grace, Christians journey through death to resurrection."  But he omits the fact that Christians can also reject God's grace.  They can reject it so severely, that they place themselves in a state of mortal sin.  If one dies in a state of mortal sin, eternal damnation is the result, not resurrection. Mary's Advocates illustrates how some people filing for divorce are likely in a state of mortal sin (see more). The Church needs to caution these people and teach them how to grow into repentant Christians, who can, with God's grace, get back on course, (see more) rather than remaining on the different course